FIXME: Make TProtocol Optional[TProtocol] to keep types consistent (#770)

* FIXME: Make TProtocol Optional[TProtocol] to keep types consistent

* correct test case of test_protocol_muxer

* add newsfragment

* unit test added

---------

Co-authored-by: Manu Sheel Gupta <manusheel.edu@gmail.com>

libp2p/host/basic_host.py

@@ -295,6 +295,13 @@ class BasicHost(IHost):
             )
             await net_stream.reset()
             return
+        if protocol is None:
+            logger.debug(
+                "no protocol negotiated, closing stream from peer %s",
+                net_stream.muxed_conn.peer_id,
+            )
+            await net_stream.reset()
+            return
         net_stream.set_protocol(protocol)
         if handler is None:
             logger.debug(

libp2p/protocol_muxer/multiselect.py

@@ -48,12 +48,11 @@ class Multiselect(IMultiselectMuxer):
         """
         self.handlers[protocol] = handler
 
-    # FIXME: Make TProtocol Optional[TProtocol] to keep types consistent
     async def negotiate(
         self,
         communicator: IMultiselectCommunicator,
         negotiate_timeout: int = DEFAULT_NEGOTIATE_TIMEOUT,
-    ) -> tuple[TProtocol, StreamHandlerFn | None]:
+    ) -> tuple[TProtocol | None, StreamHandlerFn | None]:
         """
         Negotiate performs protocol selection.
 
@@ -84,14 +83,14 @@ class Multiselect(IMultiselectMuxer):
                             raise MultiselectError() from error
 
                     else:
-                        protocol = TProtocol(command)
+                        protocol_to_check = None if not command else TProtocol(command)
-                        if protocol in self.handlers:
+                        if protocol_to_check in self.handlers:
                             try:
-                                await communicator.write(protocol)
+                                await communicator.write(command)
                             except MultiselectCommunicatorError as error:
                                 raise MultiselectError() from error
 
-                            return protocol, self.handlers[protocol]
+                            return protocol_to_check, self.handlers[protocol_to_check]
                         try:
                             await communicator.write(PROTOCOL_NOT_FOUND_MSG)
                         except MultiselectCommunicatorError as error:

libp2p/protocol_muxer/multiselect_client.py

@@ -134,8 +134,10 @@ class MultiselectClient(IMultiselectClient):
         :raise MultiselectClientError: raised when protocol negotiation failed
         :return: selected protocol
         """
+        # Represent `None` protocol as an empty string.
+        protocol_str = protocol if protocol is not None else ""
         try:
-            await communicator.write(protocol)
+            await communicator.write(protocol_str)
         except MultiselectCommunicatorError as error:
             raise MultiselectClientError() from error
 
@@ -145,7 +147,7 @@ class MultiselectClient(IMultiselectClient):
         except MultiselectCommunicatorError as error:
             raise MultiselectClientError() from error
 
-        if response == protocol:
+        if response == protocol_str:
             return protocol
         if response == PROTOCOL_NOT_FOUND_MSG:
             raise MultiselectClientError("protocol not supported")

libp2p/protocol_muxer/multiselect_communicator.py

@@ -30,7 +30,10 @@ class MultiselectCommunicator(IMultiselectCommunicator):
         """
         :raise MultiselectCommunicatorError: raised when failed to write to underlying reader
         """  # noqa: E501
-        msg_bytes = encode_delim(msg_str.encode())
+        if msg_str is None:
+            msg_bytes = encode_delim(b"")
+        else:
+            msg_bytes = encode_delim(msg_str.encode())
         try:
             await self.read_writer.write(msg_bytes)
         except IOException as error:

libp2p/security/security_multistream.py

@@ -17,6 +17,9 @@ from libp2p.custom_types import (
 from libp2p.peer.id import (
     ID,
 )
+from libp2p.protocol_muxer.exceptions import (
+    MultiselectError,
+)
 from libp2p.protocol_muxer.multiselect import (
     Multiselect,
 )
@@ -104,7 +107,7 @@ class SecurityMultistream(ABC):
         :param is_initiator: true if we are the initiator, false otherwise
         :return: selected secure transport
         """
-        protocol: TProtocol
+        protocol: TProtocol | None
         communicator = MultiselectCommunicator(conn)
         if is_initiator:
             # Select protocol if initiator
@@ -114,5 +117,7 @@ class SecurityMultistream(ABC):
         else:
             # Select protocol if non-initiator
             protocol, _ = await self.multiselect.negotiate(communicator)
+        if protocol is None:
+            raise MultiselectError("fail to negotiate a security protocol")
         # Return transport from protocol
         return self.transports[protocol]

libp2p/stream_muxer/muxer_multistream.py

@@ -17,6 +17,9 @@ from libp2p.custom_types import (
 from libp2p.peer.id import (
     ID,
 )
+from libp2p.protocol_muxer.exceptions import (
+    MultiselectError,
+)
 from libp2p.protocol_muxer.multiselect import (
     Multiselect,
 )
@@ -73,7 +76,7 @@ class MuxerMultistream:
         :param conn: conn to choose a transport over
         :return: selected muxer transport
         """
-        protocol: TProtocol
+        protocol: TProtocol | None
         communicator = MultiselectCommunicator(conn)
         if conn.is_initiator:
             protocol = await self.multiselect_client.select_one_of(
@@ -81,6 +84,8 @@ class MuxerMultistream:
             )
         else:
             protocol, _ = await self.multiselect.negotiate(communicator)
+        if protocol is None:
+            raise MultiselectError("fail to negotiate a stream muxer protocol")
         return self.transports[protocol]
 
     async def new_conn(self, conn: ISecureConn, peer_id: ID) -> IMuxedConn:

newsfragments/770.internal.rst

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+Make TProtocol as Optional[TProtocol] to keep types consistent in py-libp2p/libp2p/protocol_muxer/multiselect.py

tests/core/protocol_muxer/test_negotiate_timeout.py

@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
+from collections import deque
+
 import pytest
 import trio
 
-from libp2p.abc import (
+from libp2p.abc import IMultiselectCommunicator, INetStream
-    IMultiselectCommunicator,
-)
 from libp2p.custom_types import TProtocol
 from libp2p.protocol_muxer.exceptions import (
     MultiselectClientError,
@@ -13,6 +13,10 @@ from libp2p.protocol_muxer.multiselect import Multiselect
 from libp2p.protocol_muxer.multiselect_client import MultiselectClient
 
 
+async def dummy_handler(stream: INetStream) -> None:
+    pass
+
+
 class DummyMultiselectCommunicator(IMultiselectCommunicator):
     """
     Dummy MultiSelectCommunicator to test out negotiate timmeout.
@@ -31,7 +35,7 @@ class DummyMultiselectCommunicator(IMultiselectCommunicator):
 
 
 @pytest.mark.trio
-async def test_select_one_of_timeout():
+async def test_select_one_of_timeout() -> None:
     ECHO = TProtocol("/echo/1.0.0")
     communicator = DummyMultiselectCommunicator()
 
@@ -42,7 +46,7 @@ async def test_select_one_of_timeout():
 
 
 @pytest.mark.trio
-async def test_query_multistream_command_timeout():
+async def test_query_multistream_command_timeout() -> None:
     communicator = DummyMultiselectCommunicator()
     client = MultiselectClient()
 
@@ -51,9 +55,95 @@ async def test_query_multistream_command_timeout():
 
 
 @pytest.mark.trio
-async def test_negotiate_timeout():
+async def test_negotiate_timeout() -> None:
     communicator = DummyMultiselectCommunicator()
     server = Multiselect()
 
     with pytest.raises(MultiselectError, match="handshake read timeout"):
         await server.negotiate(communicator, 2)
+
+
+class HandshakeThenHangCommunicator(IMultiselectCommunicator):
+    handshaked: bool
+
+    def __init__(self) -> None:
+        self.handshaked = False
+
+    async def write(self, msg_str: str) -> None:
+        if msg_str == "/multistream/1.0.0":
+            self.handshaked = True
+        return
+
+    async def read(self) -> str:
+        if not self.handshaked:
+            return "/multistream/1.0.0"
+        # After handshake, hang on read.
+        await trio.sleep_forever()
+        # Should not be reached.
+        return ""
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_timeout_post_handshake() -> None:
+    communicator = HandshakeThenHangCommunicator()
+    server = Multiselect()
+    with pytest.raises(MultiselectError, match="handshake read timeout"):
+        await server.negotiate(communicator, 1)
+
+
+class MockCommunicator(IMultiselectCommunicator):
+    def __init__(self, commands_to_read: list[str]):
+        self.read_queue = deque(commands_to_read)
+        self.written_data: list[str] = []
+
+    async def write(self, msg_str: str) -> None:
+        self.written_data.append(msg_str)
+
+    async def read(self) -> str:
+        if not self.read_queue:
+            raise EOFError
+        return self.read_queue.popleft()
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_empty_string_command() -> None:
+    # server receives an empty string, which means client wants `None` protocol.
+    server = Multiselect({None: dummy_handler})
+    # Handshake, then empty command
+    communicator = MockCommunicator(["/multistream/1.0.0", ""])
+    protocol, handler = await server.negotiate(communicator)
+    assert protocol is None
+    assert handler == dummy_handler
+    # Check that server sent back handshake and the protocol confirmation (empty string)
+    assert communicator.written_data == ["/multistream/1.0.0", ""]
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_with_none_handler() -> None:
+    # server has None handler, client sends "" to select it.
+    server = Multiselect({None: dummy_handler, TProtocol("/proto1"): dummy_handler})
+    # Handshake, then empty command
+    communicator = MockCommunicator(["/multistream/1.0.0", ""])
+    protocol, handler = await server.negotiate(communicator)
+    assert protocol is None
+    assert handler == dummy_handler
+    # Check written data: handshake, protocol confirmation
+    assert communicator.written_data == ["/multistream/1.0.0", ""]
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_with_none_handler_ls() -> None:
+    # server has None handler, client sends "ls" then empty string.
+    server = Multiselect({None: dummy_handler, TProtocol("/proto1"): dummy_handler})
+    # Handshake, ls, empty command
+    communicator = MockCommunicator(["/multistream/1.0.0", "ls", ""])
+    protocol, handler = await server.negotiate(communicator)
+    assert protocol is None
+    assert handler == dummy_handler
+    # Check written data: handshake, ls response, protocol confirmation
+    assert communicator.written_data[0] == "/multistream/1.0.0"
+    assert "/proto1" in communicator.written_data[1]
+    # Note: `ls` should not list the `None` protocol.
+    assert "None" not in communicator.written_data[1]
+    assert "\n\n" not in communicator.written_data[1]
+    assert communicator.written_data[2] == ""

tests/core/protocol_muxer/test_protocol_muxer.py

@@ -159,3 +159,41 @@ async def test_get_protocols_returns_all_registered_protocols():
     protocols = ms.get_protocols()
 
     assert set(protocols) == {p1, p2, p3}
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_optional_tprotocol(security_protocol):
+    with pytest.raises(Exception):
+        await perform_simple_test(
+            None,
+            [None],
+            [None],
+            security_protocol,
+        )
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_optional_tprotocol_client_none_server_no_none(
+    security_protocol,
+):
+    with pytest.raises(Exception):
+        await perform_simple_test(None, [None], [PROTOCOL_ECHO], security_protocol)
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_optional_tprotocol_client_none_in_list(security_protocol):
+    expected_selected_protocol = PROTOCOL_ECHO
+    await perform_simple_test(
+        expected_selected_protocol,
+        [None, PROTOCOL_ECHO],
+        [PROTOCOL_ECHO],
+        security_protocol,
+    )
+
+
+@pytest.mark.trio
+async def test_negotiate_optional_tprotocol_server_none_client_other(
+    security_protocol,
+):
+    with pytest.raises(Exception):
+        await perform_simple_test(None, [PROTOCOL_ECHO], [None], security_protocol)